Professor Franklin
Accessibility settings

Preferences are saved in this browser when storage is available.

Chapter 1 · Reading 5 of 6

Security Controls

Security+ SY0-801 · Objectives 1.1

At the start of registration, the registrar asks a simple question. Can anyone who no longer works in advising still enter the records room or export the appointment list? “Only current, authorized staff may access advising records” is a control objective. A control is a specific safeguard the college uses to achieve that objective. A gap analysis compares the desired state with evidence of the actual state. A badge assigned to a former employee is one such gap.

Classify the action, then classify its purpose

Security+ distinguishes four control categories by how the safeguard is implemented. Identify the particular action in the question. A door-entry system, an identity program or a vulnerability-management program can contain several categories.

  • Managerial (administrative). Leadership establishes direction, ownership and oversight. The registrar sets the access standard, assigns responsibility for reviewing exceptions and approves the frequency of review. Evidence includes the approved standard and the signed decision on an exception.
  • Operational. People carry out a security procedure as part of running the service. Every Friday the access coordinator compares the active badge list with the personnel roster, investigates mismatches and files removal requests. The control depends on that person doing the reconciliation. A dated comparison and tracked exceptions show whether it operated.
  • Technical (logical). A system enforces a rule or performs a security check. When the identity service automatically denies an expired credential, the software performs the control. Its configuration and a test denial provide evidence. A person originally configured it, but the system makes each enforcement decision.
  • Physical (environmental). A material safeguard protects a place, equipment or people. The locked records-room door restricts entry and the cabinet protects paper files. Inspect the barrier and test whether it actually secures the intended space.

What makes a control operational?

Look for the actor, the procedure and the decision or action that produces protection. An alerting service automatically flags repeated badge denials. That detection is technical. A campus security officer reviews the alerts, checks the duty roster, contacts the shift supervisor and escalates unexplained entries. That review is operational. The fact that both steps use the same console does not change who performs each step.

Consider a departure reported on Thursday. The review policy exists, the software generates Friday’s list and the door lock still works. If nobody compares the list with the departure record, the operational control was missed. A report-generation timestamp proves the list existed. The completed reconciliation and disposition of the stale badge show what staff did with it. In an exam scenario, verbs such as reconciles, escorts and verifies by callback are useful clues when the subject is a person following an established procedure.

Control types describe the intended effect

A preventive control blocks an unwanted action, such as denying a former advisor’s export request. A deterrent discourages an attempt, such as a visible notice that access is monitored. A detective control identifies an event or deviation, such as the coordinator finding a stale grant. A corrective control remedies an identified problem, such as revoking that grant and verifying the denial.

A directive control tells people what they must do. The campus visitor policy requires an escort. A compensating control provides alternative protection when the normal safeguard cannot be used. During a badge-reader replacement, a staffed checkpoint that verifies identity against the authorized roster can serve as a temporary compensating control. Its adequacy depends on staffing, coverage and review. The written instruction is managerial and directive. The actual identity check is operational and preventive. Calling it compensating explains why that alternative is in place.

Return to the registrar’s question. Give the owner the policy that defines authorized access, the technical denial, the completed staff review and the physical inspection. Each answers a different part of the question, and each can fail while the others continue to work.

Advising records-room access review

Inspect the three records, then use the evidence to answer the question.

1. Policy

R1 / Registrar requires weekly access reviews.

2. Badge service

R2 / Badge service automatically denies expired credentials.

3. Staff review

R3 / Coordinator reconciles the badge list with the staff roster and investigates mismatches.

Apply the reading

If the badge service generates a list on Friday and no one reviews it, which control failed? What evidence would demonstrate completion?

Compare your reasoning

The operational review failed. A dated reconciliation identifying the reviewer, exceptions and their disposition shows completion. Generating the list only documents the automated step.